Making chapter plans
I need to make a plan for the next and possibly final thesis chapter. In order to do that, I should sum up what I have already done, and restate the goal of my research.
So the question I am trying to answer is "What did the ancient Greek person experience at a sanctuary of Asklepios? What did they experience in religious healing?" We can break down this question around the following axes:
- what is the built and natural landscape of the sanctuaries of Asklepios in our case studies
- how did people perceive and use them: ie, sensory dimension, theories of perception, practice, experiencing place, movement, landscape
- what is the social landscape of the sanctuaries of Asklepios: ie, who went there, why, what did they do there, what sort of social intercourse took place, how does it relate to other kinds of interactions with healing practices in antiquity
- what is involved in religious healing itself: ie compare modern and ancient material, look for ways to using modern comparative material to illuminate ways ancient people may have used or experienced or understood religious healing in antiquity
- combined with social and perceptional questions as well is the issue of what the ancient Greek person experienced in sickness, and how we should understand sickness and health in the ancient world: the context for religious healing
So I have good material for the first bulletpoint, the theory bulletpoint, and the comparative bulletpoint. And I have inadequate but decent attempted hacks at the idea of sickness and health, which I can fix in draft. So what I really need to focus on is the social world of the sanctuary: in particular the social intercourse and interactions, who was there, why, relationship to professional medicine. So I need to dig up everything on Aelius Aristides, everything on Greek public physicians, everything about how medical doctors interacted with each other and their patients... other things as they occur to me.
Aelius Aristides is our one source from inside a sanctuary. Also need focus on Galen, medical training at Pergamon? Public physicians. Inscriptions. Herodas's 4th mime again. Lucian?
Okay. I think that's an outline of a plan. Time to hit the library catalogue and make lists.
So the question I am trying to answer is "What did the ancient Greek person experience at a sanctuary of Asklepios? What did they experience in religious healing?" We can break down this question around the following axes:
- what is the built and natural landscape of the sanctuaries of Asklepios in our case studies
- how did people perceive and use them: ie, sensory dimension, theories of perception, practice, experiencing place, movement, landscape
- what is the social landscape of the sanctuaries of Asklepios: ie, who went there, why, what did they do there, what sort of social intercourse took place, how does it relate to other kinds of interactions with healing practices in antiquity
- what is involved in religious healing itself: ie compare modern and ancient material, look for ways to using modern comparative material to illuminate ways ancient people may have used or experienced or understood religious healing in antiquity
- combined with social and perceptional questions as well is the issue of what the ancient Greek person experienced in sickness, and how we should understand sickness and health in the ancient world: the context for religious healing
So I have good material for the first bulletpoint, the theory bulletpoint, and the comparative bulletpoint. And I have inadequate but decent attempted hacks at the idea of sickness and health, which I can fix in draft. So what I really need to focus on is the social world of the sanctuary: in particular the social intercourse and interactions, who was there, why, relationship to professional medicine. So I need to dig up everything on Aelius Aristides, everything on Greek public physicians, everything about how medical doctors interacted with each other and their patients... other things as they occur to me.
Aelius Aristides is our one source from inside a sanctuary. Also need focus on Galen, medical training at Pergamon? Public physicians. Inscriptions. Herodas's 4th mime again. Lucian?
Okay. I think that's an outline of a plan. Time to hit the library catalogue and make lists.